From the Outside Looking In.....
| Author | Message |
|---|---|
|
Martin Saffer
Aug 17, 2009
7:49 am
|
From the Outside Looking In.....
I received this email and thought it might give pause to reflect. I post it with permission of the sender: > I've been a regular visitor to the county since the 1960s and always dreamed about living here someday. My wife and I finally saved enough money to buy a place adjoining Watoga State Park and then swapped it for a beautiful farm off Lobelia Road. It's a heavenly little place with an old farmhouse, a creaky old barn, and a cave. Caving is what got me to WV in the first place and the natural beauty and friendly natives kept me coming back. >> The entire experience was financially and emotionally challenging and last week it took a turn for the worse. First it was the Inter-american Trade Corridor, then the quarry on Brown's Mtn, then the dreaded wind turbines, and still looming is the oil and gas thing (I don't own the mineral rights. My realtor said it was never a issue around here.) As if all of that wasn't enough, we drove to the farm last week and discovered that the place next to ours was being subdivided into Lobelia Farm Estates by one of our local realtors. She had an ad in the Times and apparently is doing this all over the county. How rude is it to do something like this without even talking to the neighboring landowners? >> We drove back to Maryland with heavy hearts wondering if the solitude and privacy that attracted us to Pocahontas County will still be there for us to enjoy once we retire. All of our plans are on hold. West Virginia may not be the place for us anymore and it's tearing me up. >> Sorry to whine, but I really love this place and now feel like my childhood dreams are falling apart. I'm not sure what to do now, but thanks for the chance to release some of the stress. >> Regards, >> Les Vilchek |
|
JIm
Aug 17, 2009
5:52 pm
|
Re: From the Outside Looking In.....
Please, This guy actually wants everyone to yield to him so he can have it his way and only his way. |
|
Martin Saffer
Aug 17, 2009
5:54 pm
|
Re: From the Outside Looking In.....
I disagree. I think his letter reflects the County's lack of a common vision. |
|
normanalderman
Aug 17, 2009
7:42 pm
|
Re: From the Outside Looking In.....
"lack of a common vision"--That's code for "we don't have zoning" Thank goodness we don't. We haven't had zoning in the past and if we had zoning good folks like the ones in the above letter wouldn't have found it so inspiring. Wonder how Pocahontas County stayed that way so long without zoning? Why would you want to "fix" it with government regulation? |
|
Linda gibb
Aug 18, 2009
1:07 am
|
Re: From the Outside Looking In.....
Norman, |
|
normanalderman
Aug 18, 2009
5:27 am
|
Re: From the Outside Looking In.....
Linda, What's broken? People are coming from zoned areas all over the United States and buying Pocahontas Property which is not zoned. Isn't the system working? They actually prefer communities without government regulation. They would rather retire to a community without regulation. Your case is unusual. There are amenities in your situation. But we are talking about people who want to live and retire in Pocahontas County. We have never had zoning (with the exception of floodplain zoing) and as a result people are flocking to Pocahontas County. The are voting AGAINST ZONING with their feet and their hearts. |
|
Martin Saffer
Aug 18, 2009
7:31 am
|
Re: From the Outside Looking In.....
Planning and looking at coordinated action to achieve a common vision is not zoning; it is a method to insure success. Inconsistent and opposing actions which are not coordinated or thought out in advance causes a "traffic accident" of results. Nobody is telling you want to do! I am only asking that we think before we leap! |
|
Joe Ferretti
Aug 18, 2009
10:27 am
|
Re: From the Outside Looking In.....
I bought property in Pocahontas County and never looked to see if zoning exists. I bought in a planned community with covenants and restrictions and I am glad we have them. C&R's protect my investment and ensure tranquility and appropriate uses. They also allow us to plan ahead with capital improvements (road maintenance, utilities, etc) and capital accumulation. I will take that over a lack of structure anytime. I live in the fastest growing county in WV. We don't have zoning because a lot of folks don't want government "interference" with their property rights. So what we have here are an abundance of strip clubs, billboards, and non-conforming uses of property. It is commonplace to see a business established in a residential area. We have a business selling sex toys and clothing within 1000 feet of a school. The developers are mainly out of state folks who take advantage of the lack of local control, build crap, and then leave with the money, leaving us with the problems. I bought in Pocahontas County because of the county that you are: rural, undeveloped, and scenic. Some may accuse me of trying to close the door behind me but that is not it at all. I hope that more folks will invest, buy property and build homes here. That way my investment maintains value. The existence of national forest will always ensure we have green space. What I want most is for those folks inclined to come here to be greeted with a plan and vision as to what Pocahontas County will become. A plan, vision, goals and forethought will support growth and investment. Unpredictability and uncertainty as to the direction of development and infrastructure will actually impede growth. Who will want to come here if you don't know what's around the bend except for the out of state developers who have ruined my own county, only to leave us holding the bag? |
|
Linda gibb
Aug 20, 2009
2:23 am
|
Re: From the Outside Looking In.....
I'd like to add an "AMEN" to Joe's posting. |
|
been here
Aug 20, 2009
9:39 pm
|
Re: From the Outside Looking In.....
to all the people talking about buying land in poca.co .if zoning was in place would you have been able to buy the property you own now.if you limit the houses then you limit the number of people .developers don't build houses that they can't sell.as far as i am concerned,too many outsiders are moving in and trying to tell us what we need to do.if you like zoning then move to somewhere they have zoning,if not then when in rome do as the romans do |
|
normanalderman
Aug 20, 2009
11:36 pm
|
Re: From the Outside Looking In.....
To Been here: I agree! There are plenty of places that have zoning. Folks who like to have the gov run their lives would simply be happier where the gov wants to run their lives. I don't want the gov running mine. I just don't need the help! Why would someone who loves zoning so much buy a house in a county that wasn't zoned? Plus, we wouldn't have Snowshoe today if we had zoning! It was actually zoned "open space". |
|
Linda gibb
Aug 21, 2009
9:15 am
|
Re: From the Outside Looking In.....
Norman, I thought you said PC didn't have zoning??? |
|
normanalderman
Aug 21, 2009
2:17 pm
|
Re: From the Outside Looking In.....
It doesn't with the exception of floodplain zoning. A study done in the early 70's proposed a zoning system which would have stopped Snowshoe dead in the water. How many jobs would have been lost? We wouldn't have been able to employ as many people from South America as we do now! |
|
Joe Ferretti
Aug 22, 2009
4:49 pm
|
Re: From the Outside Looking In.....
Norman, to say zoning would have stopped Snowshoe is quite a reach. With zoning comes a board of zoning appeals and if any non-conforming use is pursued the appeals board hears from both sides and decides first whether the zoning affects the proposed use and second, whether a variance is in order. I doubt whether any zoning appeals board would stop such a venture if the then existing zoning would have prohibited a ski resort. Been here, I hear your argument all the time about "newcomers" who want to "change" things. I think it is wise to keep an open mind about the ideas and experiences of "newcomers". I have lived in zoned and unzoned counties and in my opinion there is no comparison. The second fastest growing county in the state of WV has zoning and has had it for years. They build homes at breakneck speed and they just added a new high school to handle the growth. They have employers who employ 1000+ people and their growth is directed for maximum efficiency with county services and local government. They maintain green space and make sure that adequate resources (water) are available. The "newcomers" you should fear are out of state companies who come and leave quickly, leaving behind a mess for you to clean up and pay for. Zoning does not stop development. It just ensures we have adequate safeguards in place that will save the taxpayers and permanent residents money down the road. |
|
been here
Aug 22, 2009
5:15 pm
|
Re: From the Outside Looking In.....
i travel a lot in other states and see quite a few signs for zoning changes. if you have enough money you can get anything you want zoned to meet your needs.i also have seen a lot of people charged with taking bribes or conflict of interest.as zoning boards change so do the laws. what may be legal one day may not be legal the next.if zoning is so great why are there so many screwed up places. |
|
Joe Ferretti
Aug 22, 2009
5:55 pm
|
Re: From the Outside Looking In.....
Been here, call it the "human element". If incompetency and illegalities were the benchmarks, we would do away with just about everything. You want to see screwed up, come up to Berkeley County where we have a fine tradition of no zoning. Traffic accidents and deaths way up in numbers because our roads are not designed for the traffic we now have. Failed wells way up because we build where water is scarce. Private sewage systems failing because contractors were allowed to build as they saw fit. Guess who picks up the price tag for these and other problems caused by a lack of planning? You and I. I am not advocating stopping development. In fact, I own my own business and depend on more people moving in. I just want those people moving to places where the roads can handle them, where water is plentiful and where sewage can be handled safely. I trust my local officials I voted in to do the job right. If they don't, I vote to get rid of them. But I don't throw the baby out with the bath water!! |
|
normanalderman
Aug 22, 2009
6:14 pm
|
Re: From the Outside Looking In.....
Been here has it right. Zoning is a gateway drug for corruption. It opens the door to bribery and crime. |
|
Joe Ferretti
Aug 22, 2009
6:21 pm
|
Re: From the Outside Looking In.....
Norman, so does police protection and criminal laws. So is local government on many levels. (And you have pointed that out numerous times on here) Do you advocate that we do away with the police also or is it better to get the right people for the job? |
|
been here
Aug 22, 2009
7:39 pm
|
Re: From the Outside Looking In.....
look at the mess about the sewer system at snowshoe.if you have a zoning board that don;t agree with the co. com. you have to wait till their term is up before they can be replaced.people with money can affect the out come of elections.the people that is voted in may not be the one i voted for.if you can only build in certain places guess who will own them/ |
|
JIm
Aug 22, 2009
8:35 pm
|
Re: From the Outside Looking In.....
Zoning with common sense is not a bad thing, however I have never seen a zoning commission that had common sense or was in touch with reality. Brace ypurself Norman, Zoning is coming and not in a good way. |
|
normanalderman
Aug 22, 2009
10:01 pm
|
Re: From the Outside Looking In.....
We have learned the hard way what it is like to have a three person board who won't do their job. We don't want a zoning board too! |
|
Linda gibb
Aug 23, 2009
12:21 am
|
Re: From the Outside Looking In.....
Norman, I still think that a vision is needed to prevent helter-skelter development all over the place. YOu need to decide in what areas you want industrial parks, manufacturing, homes, medical, & yes ski resorts. You never did answer my question of how you would like it if some developer would buy your adjoining property & put in a strip club? Might be a goodl place for such a thing, way out there in the countrty away from school & kids. How would you like that??? |
|
Martin Saffer
Aug 23, 2009
7:08 am
|
Re: From the Outside Looking In.....
My mother had an expression she used often to describe the rapid pace of life: "Burning the candle at both ends...but what a lovely light!" To me this describes well the point we are in the world today where economies seem to depend on every one buying and spending in a rapid rate to sustain constant growth. Its a lovely light but that candle is going to go out faster than you think. Perhaps not in your lifetime but in foreseeable generations. You can already see that forests and clean water and fresh air and open spaces are being consumed in this double flame. The flame of progress is nipping at our resources too. I believe the time to think and plan is at hand. Again planning is not telling anyone what to do; its having an intelligent talk about what is our best common course of action for tomorrow. |
|
Pat Stump
Aug 23, 2009
9:43 am
|
Re: From the Outside Looking In.....
I personally believe the county would benefit from a five person county commission. I think it would afford better representation for such a large geographic area. How many people would you propose serve on a county-wide planning commission? |
|
Martin Saffer
Aug 23, 2009
1:47 pm
|
Re: From the Outside Looking In.....
I don't think a Planning Commission or group, if one were to materialize, should be the County Commission itself. If separate, it would be less political. But I do agree at least five or maybe even a ten member planning group to get a big cross section of opinion. Planning to me is really about talking and communication not about formulating regulations or rules. But if past experience is any indicator, it would need to have a formal existence, budget and defined mission. |
|
been here
Aug 23, 2009
2:19 pm
|
Re: From the Outside Looking In.....
the best common course is for people to decide what is best for them.i know of some people who had to sell off part of their property to help take care of their mother or help pay for college or bills.i know a lot of people that gave part of their property to their children and granchildren to live on.would this type of subdivision be allowed under your plans.what people like and don't like or the value of their property has nothing to do with what is right or wrong. |
|
normanalderman
Aug 23, 2009
3:16 pm
|
Re: From the Outside Looking In.....
I have three potential persons for your zoning board: Mark Smith |
|
Martin Saffer
Aug 23, 2009
6:42 pm
|
Re: From the Outside Looking In.....
Again, I see no harm in people talking and trying to reach common ground. This bug-boo chatter about "zoning" really gets the conversation stalled every time. The idea that somehow we are islands isolated and disconnected from others in our activities doesn't wash with reality. We are in a community, in fact in many communities at once: our work place, our church, our schools, our neighbors, our neighborhoods, our circle of friends etc. In these groups and areas our actions are not disconnected at all. Likewise, our use of our property effects and concerns our neighbors. |
|
freeholder
Aug 23, 2009
7:54 pm
|
Re: From the Outside Looking In.....
Dear Commissioners: Perhaps you could enlarge the knowledge base of countywide planning by sponsoring a contest : Let only high school students submit a plan with diagrams and maps, text etc. and offer a reward of several hundred or more dollars.I see it as a good idea as well to have an engineer or other professional from another county to be the judge.Such a contest would introduce the topic of planning and zoning to the young people : I would like to see their comments as well as their plans . Too, when they get older and get to vote, they will have needed information on this emotional point. This contest possibly would help move the discussion to a new level, making it more interesting.Some students may influence their elders to reconsider planning. |
|
Linda gibb
Aug 24, 2009
1:18 am
|
Re: From the Outside Looking In.....
Freeholder, that's a great idea, but where would the money come from for the reward? |
|
Martin Saffer
Aug 24, 2009
8:08 am
|
Re: From the Outside Looking In.....
Now that was a very good idea...engaging our young people into the political process as well as asking them about the course of their own future. I hope on that "map of ideas" they draw a community college. |
|
freeholder
Aug 24, 2009
6:43 pm
|
Re: From the Outside Looking In.....
A possible source for the reward money would be from the BOE or the Public Relations Dept. or publicity and advertising fund.or maybe a private or business donor. Snowshoe? |
|
Martin Saffer
Aug 26, 2009
10:16 am
|
Re: From the Outside Looking In.....
I called the High School and hope to discuss with the Civics Class teacher the idea of a project like a "map of ideas" for the students to articulate their future in the County. The best way to get somewhere is to draw a map! |
|
Michael Holstine
Aug 26, 2009
10:49 am
|
Re: From the Outside Looking In.....
Martin, I will donate $500 to the PCHS right now, on behalf of the NRAO, as a project award for this "Planning the Future of Pocahontas County" mapping idea. Just as a farmer 'plans' the future crops for his fields and businesses 'plan' for the necessary future outlay of their cash reserves, Pocahontas County absolutely must 'plan' for it's future by engaging in discussion and foresight. There is excellence in the method of having the youth participate in this discussion in a meaningful way, and should provide opportunity for real and hands-on learning about the County and the processes that go into running its 'business'. Let me know if this will become a reality and I will get the money to them. |
|
Linda gibb
Aug 27, 2009
1:44 am
|
Re: From the Outside Looking In.....
Thanks Mike/NRAO. I hope this idea takes off. After all the county belongs to all of its' residents, young & old. |
|
been here
Aug 28, 2009
7:30 pm
|
Re: From the Outside Looking In.....
michael is this your money or nrao money. |
|
Michael Holstine
Aug 28, 2009
8:39 pm
|
Re: From the Outside Looking In.....
This would be private money, not NRAO money. |
|
Martin Saffer
Aug 29, 2009
6:10 am
|
Re: From the Outside Looking In.....
I talked with Nancy Martin and she agreed to introduce this idea to her class and invited me to share this important concept with them. I am very pleased to "talk future" with those who are "our future". And as I think about this idea, more than a contribution graciously offered by from someone like Mr. Holstine, I would want him instead to perhaps share personally his perspective to students as well. As an aside, I went to Sheriff's day at PCHS for a mock murder trial last Saturday and I think this kind of street level involvement of reality and young people is very rewarding. Sheriff Jonese has a very good grasp on the importance of community involvement and education as a component of law enforcement. He is doing outstanding work in this regard. |